For decades, owning your own home was considered the cornerstone of the “Cypriot dream”. In recent years, however, many have questioned whether buying a home is a (financially) rational decision and whether it is a better option than renting. You will certainly have heard advice such as “renting is throwing your money away” or “buying a house is not a good investment”. Although both may hold true in some cases, the decision to buy or rent is far more complex than these generalisations suggest.
The conditions created by the coronavirus pandemic, and the need for many employees to work from home, sharply increased the use of the home as a workplace, raising new questions about buying versus renting. At the same time, it is almost expected that many businesses will include some form of remote working in their business models in the future.
So if we try to rationalise this dilemma, the answer will depend (i) entirely on each person’s financial goals, (ii) the capital they have available and (iii) their future plans, as reflected in the following four questions.
1. Do you know all the costs?
The purchase price of a home and your purchasing power are the obvious factors in the decision. To make the right decision, however, it is important to build a complete picture of the financial side. A new buyer should add several factors to the purchase price, such as:
- When borrowing: the opportunity cost of the initial down payment (banks usually require around 20% as your own contribution), the interest rate, various bank charges (property valuation, documentation fees and so on), loan insurance and more.
- Other initial or recurring costs, such as home insurance, property taxes, municipal services (sewerage, refuse collection fees and so on), running costs (electricity, water, heating and so on) and maintenance of the home.
Taken together, all of the above significantly increase the cost of ownership and affect your ability to repay. Conversely, most of these expenses are eliminated or reduced when renting, since they are borne by the landlord.
2. Do property values fall?
Before the property market collapse that began in 2008, many took it for granted that house prices rise every year, creating capital appreciation that was often enough to cover the cost of ownership described above. That is not always the case. The bursting of the property bubble in 2010 showed that house prices can fall significantly. As a result of the (local and global) public and banking debt crisis, and the excessive accumulation of unsold properties, both transactions and values fell sharply in Cyprus after 2008, especially up to 2015. More specifically, these market conditions led to a steep drop in prices of around 35% between 2010 and 2015 (RICS Cyprus).
Mirroring the real economy, the first signs of recovery appeared in 2016. During 2018–19 house prices continued to rise overall, though with significant differences depending on parameters such as property type and location. Two factors probably played an important role in the increased demand:
- Higher domestic purchasing power, thanks to an overall improvement in the real economy, lower unemployment, more available bank lending at lower interest rates and a lack of higher-yielding alternative investments (very low deposit rates with a risk to capital, no meaningful equity or bond market).
- Capital inflows from foreign buyers through the Cyprus Investment Programme (CIP) and the permanent residency (PR) scheme and, to a lesser extent, Cypriots returning home for many different reasons.
In addition, the reduced supply of houses and apartments during a period when the construction sector lacked the capital to invest played a part in rising prices, particularly for apartments, and is also the main reason rents rose significantly in this period.
3. What is happening to rents and yields on apartments and houses in Cyprus?
Rents and yields followed the general trend of the property sector (and of the economy) through the various phases of the last decade. According to the RICS Cyprus Property Index, rents for houses and apartments recovered from the steep fall of 2010–2015, rising by around 33% for both types between 2016 and 2019. Yields, on the other hand, remained fairly stable and at satisfactory levels throughout the period, despite the significant price correction. A small increase was recorded in 2019 compared with 2018, at 7.2% for houses and 5.6% for apartments. It should be noted that a combination of low yields and higher borrowing rates reduces the investment value of property, since it makes borrowing to invest in an apartment or house to let only marginally profitable.
Shortly before the COVID-19 pandemic broke out, the only category of property expected to see a rise in yield was apartments. In our view this is for four main reasons: (i) they require less capital to buy than other asset classes, (ii) they are easier to let (a source of income), (iii) demand for apartments near universities exceeds supply and (iv) young couples mostly prefer to rent an apartment rather than buy one.
| Price range | Average price per m² | Monthly rent | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apartments | €160K – €170K | €1,500 – €2,000 | €500 – €650 |
| Houses | €375K – €530K | €1,500 – €2,000 | €800 – €1,100 |
4. What are your future plans?
Your future plans and goals, including how long you expect to stay and your professional, financial and family situation, have a big impact on whether it makes more sense to buy or to rent.
How long do you plan to stay in the home?
As mentioned, when renting you do not need to worry about all the extra costs of ownership. You also have the freedom to move elsewhere at any time, which may be more advantageous. Renting appears to be a good option for young professionals, people who travel a lot, and those who want the freedom to move often or are waiting for the right time to buy. It is worth noting that rents in Cyprus have risen significantly over the last three years. For people such as married couples, or those planning to have a child soon, buying may be the more attractive option.
In conclusion
Both renting and owning a home have their advantages and disadvantages. You should weigh the pros and cons of each and decide which makes more sense given your own circumstances. Once you have decided what your priorities and goals are, take the steps needed to achieve them.